Publications
Affinity insurance: legal framework, client rights and points of vigilance
Affinity insurance: legal framework, client rights and points of vigilance
Understand affinity insurance: legal framework, client rights, distributors' obligations and the main points of vigilance to be aware of.
Affinity insurance is everywhere: an extended warranty on a smartphone, breakage cover for a household appliance, travel cancellation cover, protection for a means of payment. Offered alongside a purchase, it is a fast-growing market, but also one of the sectors most criticised by the ACPR and consumer associations.
Between information obligations, a strengthened right of withdrawal and closely scrutinised distribution practices, market players must master a legal framework that has become stricter.
This article provides an overview of affinity insurance: its definition, its legal framework, the client's rights and the points of vigilance for distributors.
What is affinity insurance?
Affinity insurance covers a specific activity within the insurance sector. An affinity insurance contract is an insurance contract taken out in addition to a good or service sold by a supplier. It is defined as cover that is intrinsically linked to a product or service, of which it is an ancillary element rather than the main purpose of the purchase. The French Insurance Code does not provide a stand-alone or dedicated definition of the legal framework for affinity insurance, but several texts govern this specific model.
First, Article L 513.1 of the French Insurance Code defines the category of so-called “exempt” insurance products. These contracts match the definition of affinity insurance in every respect, since their sole purpose is to supplement the purchase of a good or service.
However, the nature of the cover (essentially property damage cover) and the amount of the annual or temporary premiums are strictly limited by law (€200 for temporary insurance and €600 for annual contracts with tacit renewal). This allows suppliers who distribute such insurance alongside the goods or services they sell to avoid the regulatory constraints associated with registration with ORIAS and with compliance with the conditions for carrying on insurance distribution activities.
Next, there is Article L.112-10 of the French Insurance Code, created by the Hamon Act of 17 March 2014.
In practice, affinity insurance covers specific risks listed by law:
- the malfunction, loss (including theft) or damage of a good supplied,
- risks linked to travel (damage to or loss of luggage, and other ancillary risks),
- or the loss or theft of means of payment.
It typically concerns high-tech products, household appliances, travel, mobile telephony, bank cards… but without any limit: any product or service may in itself give rise to a need for dedicated insurance.
The Fédération des garanties et assurances affinitaires (FG2A, the French federation of affinity insurance and warranties) defines it as any insurance or assistance cover or ancillary service relating to the world of a product or service distributed by a non-insurer distributor, and which is not the client's main reason for purchase. It is this ancillary dimension that makes the product both attractive and sensitive.
Who distributes affinity insurance, and under what status?
Affinity insurance is largely distributed by players whose core business is not insurance. Understanding who distributes it and under what status is essential, as this determines the applicable obligations.
The market has attracted many players: insurers, brokers, contract administrators, but also and above all ancillary distributors (retail chains, mobile operators, sellers of high-tech products, travel agencies, e-commerce sites). When a retailer offers insurance alongside a good or service, it may act as an ancillary insurance intermediary. It is subject to the rules on professional competence and registration, unless it meets all the conditions of the exemption provided for in Article L. 513-1 of the French Insurance Code.
This distribution structure explains some of the difficulties: the seller of a product is not always trained as an insurance professional, and its commercial interest (selling the extended warranty or service) may conflict with the duty to advise. This is why the legislature and the ACPR regulate these practices closely.
What is the legal framework for affinity insurance?
The legal framework for affinity insurance has been built up in stages, mainly with a view to consumer protection. Knowing it helps to place current obligations in context.
The Hamon Act of 17 March 2014 created the category and laid down the first protections: an initial 14-day right of withdrawal, protection against multiple insurance and the possibility of terminating at any time after one year.
The Act of 16 August 2022 went further by extending the withdrawal period from 14 to 30 days, applicable since 1 January 2023.
Alongside these texts, affinity insurance remains subject to the general law on insurance distribution (IDD, duty to advise, pre-contractual information).
The sector has also been the subject of an opinion of the Financial Sector Advisory Committee (CCSF) of 29 April 2022 and of private member's bills aimed at tightening regulation (separate signature from the act of purchase, content of the renewal notice, easier termination). The framework is therefore evolving towards greater consumer protection.
What is the client's right of withdrawal?
The right of withdrawal is the central protection in affinity insurance. A sound grasp of it is essential, as failure to respect it is a major source of litigation and sanctions.
Since 1 January 2023, the policyholder has 30 days to withdraw from an affinity insurance contract, compared with 14 days previously. This right is exercised without having to give reasons or pay penalties. Where there is a free period (the first months offered free of charge), the 30-day period runs from the date of payment of all or part of the first premium, which prevents the initial free period from depriving the client of their right.
This right of withdrawal is designed in particular to combat multiple insurance: before the contract is concluded, the insurer must give the policyholder a document inviting them to check that they are not already covered for the same risk by another contract (home insurance, bank card cover), and informing them of their right of withdrawal.
Practical example: a client buys a smartphone and takes out breakage and theft insurance. However, their “premium” bank card and their home insurance already partially cover these risks. The information document must alert them to this possible overlap, and they have 30 days to withdraw if they find they are double-insured. A distributor that fails to provide proper information is exposed to a real risk.
Why does the ACPR show a degree of reservation towards affinity insurance?
Affinity insurance is the subject of a strict approach by the ACPR, which makes it a particularly closely supervised sector.
In a public statement in March 2024, the ACPR highlighted several abuses. It noted a high rejection rate for claims, of around 40% to 80% depending on the product, complex and lengthy complaints procedures, and numerous exclusions that can lead to claims being refused on unclear grounds. Above all, it stressed an unfavourable cost-benefit ratio: according to the supervisor, only a small share of premiums is actually used to pay claims, the remainder constituting the margin of distributors and insurers.
These criticisms echo those of consumer associations, which have for several years been denouncing subscriptions that are sometimes imposed (direct debits not clearly consented to), a lack of transparency and overlapping cover. Affinity insurance also accounts for a significant share of the disputes handled by the insurance ombudsman. The sector is therefore clearly in the authorities' sights.
What are the distributor's information and advice obligations?
Distributors of affinity insurance are subject to enhanced obligations, precisely because the product is ancillary and the client is often not paying close attention. Complying with them is the best protection against complaints.
Before subscription, the distributor must provide clear information on the scope of cover, the exclusions, the price, the term and the termination arrangements, as well as the document inviting the client to check that they are not multiply insured and reminding them of the right of withdrawal. It must fulfil its duty to advise: ensure that the product meets a genuine need of the client and is not redundant. The subscription must reflect free and informed consent, separate from the act of purchasing the main good.
Practical example: when selling a telephone, the seller offers an extended warranty. To be compliant, the subscription to the insurance must be the subject of a specific agreement by the client, and not slipped into the payment for the telephone. A mere debit from the account, without explicit consent to the insurance, is not sufficient to establish the consumer's agreement and exposes the distributor.
What are the risks and sanctions for market players?
Failings in the distribution of affinity insurance give rise to serious risks at several levels. Assessing them helps to prioritise compliance.
In terms of supervision, the ACPR oversees commercial practices and compliance with the duty to advise, and may impose disciplinary and financial sanctions, which are often published. The DGCCRF may intervene in respect of unfair or misleading commercial practices. In civil terms, a client who was poorly informed or subjected to a subscription they did not consent to may obtain reimbursement of the premiums and, where applicable, damages. In addition, there is a major reputational risk in a sector that is already exposed in the media.
The risk is all the greater because the questionable practices of a few players damage the image of the sector as a whole, which is prompting the authorities to harden their position. For a reputable distributor, strict compliance is also a way of standing out.
How can affinity insurance be distributed compliantly?
The winning approach is to treat affinity insurance with the same rigour as a fully-fledged insurance product, and not as a mere sales add-on. This is what secures the distributor's position and protects the client.
A few key reflexes: obtain explicit consent, separate from the act of purchasing the main good; provide clear information on cover, exclusions, price and term; hand over the document inviting the client to check that they are not multiply insured and reminding them of the 30-day right of withdrawal; fulfil the duty to advise by checking the product's genuine usefulness; make withdrawal and termination easier rather than obstructing them; handle complaints promptly and with reasons; and train sales staff acting as ancillary intermediaries.
Affinity insurance is not objectionable in itself: properly distributed, it meets a genuine need to protect everyday goods. It is opaque or imposed practices that cause problems and attract sanctions. A transparent distributor that obtains informed consent and respects the client's rights turns a much-criticised product into a valued service, while protecting itself vis-à-vis the ACPR and the DGCCRF. It is this rigour, rather than short-term commercial convenience, that secures the business over the long term.
Affinity insurance: framework, rights and vigilance
Key reference points for distributing affinity insurance compliantly. Filter by theme or search for a keyword.
